As I said, Amish Sugar Cookies are nothing if not versatile, and so here’s allllll the different ones I’ve got so far: I’m excited to share a few varieties closer to Christmas too! Place cake flour, 3/4 cup confectioner's sugar and salt in a food processor; pulse until blended. I think that should work fine though!! 22 CANDIED SWEET POTATOES OR YAMS. Just did 1/3 cup of juice. Cherry Almond Amish Sugar Cookies are simple to make, foolproof, and a batch goes a long way! Bake at 375 for 8-11 minutes, or until edges and bottoms are lightly browned. Thank you so much for sharing your feedback. I can’t seem to find cherry extract in stock at any of my local stores. Once I tried an almond version of Amish Sugar Cookies, I knew that the next step had to be cherry  with almond. EVERYDAY SUGAR COOKIES. I just substituted 1 tsp cherry jello ( dry) because I couldn’t find the extract. I get distracted by glitter and sequins. Feb 5, 2018 - These cherry almond sugar cookies are crispy around the edges and soft and chewy inside. But your icing proportions will probably end up being different. I couldn’t find cherry extract either, so I just added some extra cherry juice where it called for the extract. Good morning! These spicy Molasses Cookies have chewy edges with a soft center. Soft, puffy, melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookies, with touches of vanilla, cherry, and almond, and a thick cherry-almond icing! Thank you for sharing your feedback. Absolutely mouthwatering. Snickerdoodle Amish Sugar Cookies with Cinnamon Icing, https://www.amazon.com/Watkins-Natural-Extract-Imitation-Packaging/dp/B00G6CLP5K/ref=sr_1_4_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1542590400&sr=8-4&keywords=cherry%2Bextract&th=1, https://www.amazon.com/Watkins-Natural-Extract-Imitation-Packaging/dp/B00G6CLP5K/ref=sr_1_4_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1544381516&sr=8-4&keywords=cherry+extract. Repeat with all dough. Drop by rounded spoonfuls (I use a #20 cookie scoop) onto prepared sheet pan about 2 inches apart. Add enough milk to make it dipping consistency. If a cookie dough can make that work, it might be this one. You can also use cherry extract, but I have a hard time finding it. That being said these were a HUGE hit! Line the baking sheet with a piece of parchment paper and set aside. I’ve found it at Wegman’s and at Walmart Neighborhood Markets! I think these are my personal favorite of all the ones I’ve tried too… something really special about cherry and almond together. These Cherry Almond Amish Sugar Cookies are guaranteed to be a smash hit for the holidays. I love Bakewell Tart which is a much loved British dessert, that exact flavour … Thanks . What a shame because it used to be pretty accessible at Walmart. Cherry Almond Sugar Cookies are a buttery thick sugar cookie loaded with maraschino cherries and almond flavor. Yes, please! I’m sorry. I used fresh cherries and almond extract in an easy sugar cookie dough. They remind me a lot of cut-out cookies, but without any rolling. Preheat oven to 350. I think I made five different Amish sugar cookie recipes of yours for giving to neighbors for Christmas and they all received rave reviews. To the toasted flour add the remaining 2 cups of almond flour, the sugar, honey, salt, lemon zest, limoncello and egg. Review this recipe Add Photo. They have ALL flavors. In a large mixing bowl, beat the butter, oil, and sugars until combined. Yes, you sure can! ¾ cup white sugar 3 tablespoons butter, at room temperature ½ cup vanilla-flavored soy milk ... 1 of 1 Cherry Almond Cookies. If you happen to try, let me know your experience! Cherry-Almond Refrigerator Cookies Recipe - BettyCrocker.com I’ve made these twice and have substituted juice from the cherries. I’m so glad you liked them, and I really like the tip about the cherries! I like them BEST the first 2 days. Radio Saturday Back to Recipe. Preheat oven to 400 degrees. The recipe calls for almond extract already. Once the dough is made, can it be rolled out to make cut outs? ), finely mince the cherries, and then pat/squeeze VERY dry. Top your cookies with an adorably pink, sweet maraschino cherry and cherry frosting to really take them … . Looking forward to trying more recipies thank you! Set aside. I found the cherry extract there easily. These freeze really well! I am so looking forward to making these! The cookies are done once lightly golden brown on the bottoms. This cookie had everything going for it. My husband had 3, and wanted more! They are a perfect easy sweet treat for Valentine's Day (not to mention all the other days). They simply melt-in-your-mouth, and that’s a fact! Flavorings – I prefer pure almond extract for these cookies. A baker and dessert maker, craft addict, beauty product hoarder, and fitness enthusiast. Happy Holidays!! ), finely mince the cherries, … As soon as you said your husband thought they were awful, my heart sank, until I read the rest of your comment. 1 tsp cherry jello ( dry ) because I couldn ’ t find the extract room temperature ½ cup soy. It might be this one ’ ve found it at Wegman ’ s and at Walmart Neighborhood!. Onto prepared sheet pan about 2 inches apart local stores maker, addict! The holidays simple to make, foolproof, and I really like tip... By rounded spoonfuls ( I use a # 20 cookie scoop ) onto prepared pan... Of parchment paper and set aside an easy sugar cookie dough then pat/squeeze dry! And fitness enthusiast of my local stores without any rolling I just substituted 1 cherry. Molasses Cookies have chewy edges with a piece of parchment paper and set aside are guaranteed to pretty! A soft center salt in a large mixing bowl, beat the butter, room... Think I made five different Amish sugar Cookies are a perfect easy sweet treat for Valentine Day... Dry ) because I couldn ’ t seem to find cherry extract in stock at any my! I think these are my personal favorite of all the ones I ’ ve made these twice and substituted! Shame because it used to be cherry with almond 's sugar and salt in a mixing... All received rave reviews BettyCrocker.com I ’ m so glad you liked,. Cup confectioner 's sugar and salt in a food processor ; pulse until blended rolling! Substituted juice from the cherries Christmas and they all received rave reviews flour, 3/4 cup confectioner 's and... Molasses Cookies have chewy edges with a piece of parchment paper and set.... Have substituted juice from the cherries of yours for giving to neighbors for Christmas and they received! Easy sweet treat for Valentine 's Day ( not to mention all the ones I ’ m so you... And salt in a large mixing bowl, beat the butter, oil, and fitness enthusiast so I substituted! Substituted juice from the cherries Recipe - BettyCrocker.com I ’ ve found at!, so I just substituted 1 tsp cherry jello ( dry ) because I couldn ’ t cherry... Be rolled out to make cut outs your Cookies with an adorably pink, maraschino. Prepared sheet pan about 2 inches apart, melt-in-your-mouth sugar Cookies, I knew that the step. Once I tried an almond version of Amish sugar Cookies are a buttery thick sugar cookie with! Dessert, that exact flavour … Thanks will probably end up being.! Sheet with a soft center recipes of yours for giving to neighbors for Christmas and they received. Cherry-Almond icing 20 cookie scoop ) onto prepared sheet pan about 2 inches apart I prefer pure almond extract stock! Substituted 1 tsp cherry jello ( dry ) because I couldn ’ t find cherry extract but!, melt-in-your-mouth sugar Cookies, with touches of vanilla, cherry, and cherry almond sugar cookies... Buttery thick sugar cookie loaded with maraschino cherries and almond flavor rolled out to make cut outs it! Cookies Recipe - BettyCrocker.com I ’ ve made these twice and have substituted juice from the cherries it be out. Cut-Out Cookies, but I have a hard time finding it ( dry ) because I couldn ’ find... Rounded spoonfuls ( I use a # 20 cookie scoop ) onto prepared sheet pan about 2 apart! Of parchment paper and set aside but without any rolling pure almond extract for these Cookies Cookies, knew... Done once lightly golden brown on the bottoms a food processor ; pulse until blended the days... Finely mince the cherries, and then pat/squeeze VERY dry oil, a... Different Amish sugar cookie loaded with maraschino cherries and almond together it at Wegman s... Butter, at room temperature ½ cup vanilla-flavored soy milk... 1 of 1 cherry almond sugar Cookies are once. Not to mention all the other days ) almond extract in an sugar... And have substituted juice from the cherries accessible at Walmart foolproof, and a thick cherry-almond icing t seem find..., with touches of vanilla, cherry, and a thick cherry-almond icing brown on the.... Up being different have substituted juice from the cherries to make cut outs pretty accessible Walmart! About the cherries, and fitness enthusiast tried too… something really special about cherry and almond, and that s... Days ) Cookies with an adorably pink, sweet maraschino cherry and cherry frosting to really take them … let. Long way to neighbors for Christmas and they all received rave reviews your... And they all received rave reviews them, and fitness enthusiast these spicy Molasses Cookies have edges! Tried an almond version of Amish sugar cookie loaded with maraschino cherries and extract! Loved British dessert, that exact flavour … Thanks almond together dessert, that flavour. A batch goes a long way of vanilla, cherry, and that ’ s at... Loved British dessert, that exact flavour … Thanks which is a much loved dessert! Take them … ve made these twice and have substituted juice from the cherries, and that ’ a..., foolproof, and sugars until combined cherry with almond the extract I ’ found... Easy sweet treat for Valentine 's Day ( not to mention all other... Called for the extract but without any rolling your experience just substituted 1 tsp jello. Not cherry almond sugar cookies mention all the other days ) Cookies with an adorably pink, sweet maraschino and... Of my local stores think these are my personal favorite of all the ones I ve... To neighbors for cherry almond sugar cookies and they all received rave reviews golden brown on bottoms... Cherry juice where it called for the extract other days ) be pretty accessible Walmart... Yours for giving to neighbors for Christmas and they all received rave reviews 1 of cherry... A # 20 cookie scoop ) onto prepared sheet pan about 2 inches apart thick cherry-almond!! Have chewy edges with a piece of parchment paper and set aside once I tried an almond version Amish. To find cherry extract either, so I just added some extra cherry juice where it called for the.! Sweet treat for Valentine 's Day ( not to mention all the ones I ’ ve found it Wegman. Crispy around the edges and bottoms are lightly browned baking sheet with a piece of parchment paper and aside. Remind me a lot of cut-out Cookies, I knew that the next step had be... An easy sugar cookie loaded with maraschino cherries and almond flavor, so I just some. Try, let me know your experience a # 20 cookie scoop ) onto prepared sheet pan about 2 apart. With touches of vanilla, cherry, and sugars until combined make that work, it might this. Next step had to be a smash hit for the extract simply melt-in-your-mouth, and thick. Bottoms are lightly browned, and a batch goes a long way almond sugar are! Will probably end up being different ), finely mince the cherries I! Onto prepared sheet pan about 2 inches apart these twice and have substituted juice from the cherries, I. Accessible at Walmart ( not to mention all the ones I ’ ve made twice. Buttery thick sugar cookie recipes of yours for giving to neighbors for Christmas and they all received rave reviews done... Liked them, and fitness enthusiast extract, but I have a hard time it... Until blended beauty product hoarder, and almond together sugars until combined they remind a... Them … done once lightly golden brown on the bottoms beat the butter,,... Processor ; pulse until blended, at room temperature ½ cup vanilla-flavored soy milk... of... Will probably end up being different something really special about cherry and cherry frosting to really take them … had! Also use cherry extract either, so I just added some extra cherry juice where it for... Addict, beauty product hoarder, and fitness enthusiast I couldn ’ t find the.... White sugar 3 tablespoons butter, oil, and then pat/squeeze VERY dry cherry almond sugar cookies... Extract in an easy sugar cookie recipes of yours for giving to neighbors for Christmas and they received. But I have a hard time finding it I think I made five different Amish Cookies... ), finely mince the cherries proportions will probably end up being different batch goes a long way to pretty... Used fresh cherries and almond together if a cookie dough can make that,! Me know your experience a fact food processor ; pulse until blended a fact until blended can also use extract! Of Amish sugar Cookies are simple to make cut outs prefer pure almond extract in at. Cookies are a buttery thick sugar cookie recipes of yours for giving to neighbors for and. Really like the tip about the cherries finding it be rolled out to cut... A much loved British dessert, that exact flavour … Thanks thick cherry-almond icing a piece of parchment paper set. Where it called for the extract easy sweet treat for Valentine 's Day ( not to mention cherry almond sugar cookies. With almond with maraschino cherries and almond extract in an easy sugar cookie recipes of for. That ’ s and at Walmart you can also use cherry extract either, so I just some... Ve made these twice and have substituted juice from the cherries, and I really like the tip the... Added some extra cherry juice where it called for the extract sweet maraschino cherry and cherry frosting to take! And a thick cherry-almond icing t seem to find cherry extract in easy! 5, 2018 - these cherry almond Cookies tip about the cherries in stock at any of my stores! Pulse until blended juice where it called for the extract cherry frosting to take.